-
Topics
Archives
-
-
Recent Posts
-
-
-
-
Category Archives: Dow Theory
Dow Theory: 1903-1907
Bull market indication (A):According to Edwards & Magee's book Technical Analysis of Stock Trends, the bull market began at point A. From the point of the bull signal to the respective market tops, the DJI gained 100% and DJT gained 37%. The NLO team believes that at point (C) on 12/4/1903, the DJI confirmed the 11/30/1903 DJT signal that a bull market was in progress by exceeding the late Oct 1903 peaks. From the point of the bull signal to the respective market tops, the DJI gained 126% and DJT gained 47%.
Bear market indication (B): On 4/24/1906 the DJI confirmed the 4/19/1906 DJT bearish move. The signal came when the DJT dropped below the Sept 1905 low and the DJI dropped below the December 1905/March 1906 lows. From the point of the bear signal to the respective market bottoms, the DJI lost -42% and the DJT lost -35%. The NLO team is in agreement with the Edwards and Magee as to when the bear market began.
Please consider donating to the New Low Observer. Thank you.
Dow Theory: 1900-1903
The following is the beginning of a series that examines prior bull and bear market indications according to Dow Theory since 1900. We will include opinions and insights from the leading Dow Theory proponents and commentators from the respective periods, whenever possible.
![]() |
| Industrials (DJI), Transports (DJT) |
Text in chart:
Bull market indication (A): On 10/22/1900, the DJI confirmed the 10/16/1900 DJT signal that a bull market was in progress. From the point of the bull signal to the respective market tops, the DJI gained 29% and the DJT gained 60%.
Bear market indcation (B): A bear market indication was registered on April 13, 1903 when the DJT confirmed the 11/11/1902 DJI bearish move. The critical point that set off the bearish signal was the joint delcine below the 12/12/1901 and 12/24/1901 closing prices for the DJT and DJI, respectively. The challenge with this bear signal is the fact that the DJI was in a declining trend since June 17, 1901 while the DJT continued to register new highs at the same time not falling below the "Nipper Panic" lows of May 9, 1901. From the point of the bear signal to the respective market bottoms, the DJI lost -30% and the DJT lost -16%.
Dow Theory: Market Behaving as Expected
On August 9, 2011, we proposed that a bottom had been established in the market. Additionally, we proposed what the upside targets were based on Dow Theory.
Our assessment of where the market bottom was (based on the August 8th low) at 10,809.85 was off by 154.55 points, or 1.42%, when the Dow Industrials reached the lower level of 10,655.30 on October 3, 2011.
The purpose of pointing out bear market rally targets is to indicate where the market is expected to go on the upside. So far there is only one upside target left from the August 9th article. All that has taken place since then has been in alignment with classical Dow Theory.
On October 15, 2011, we wrote an article titled "Dow Theory: Bullish Implications." In that article we said the following:
“The coming market volatility will provide great opportunities for traders and allow investors a chance to cash out of otherwise undesirable positions and take profits. Our expectation is that the Dow will go to the July 2011 highs before struggling at the May 2011 highs.”
Historically speaking, daily gains of 2%-3% or more in the Dow Industrials is reflective of an unhealthy market. We are repeating that the current run is a golden opportunity to shed unwanted positions. It is hoped that long-term investors are in positions that are compensating for the wait, through the reinvestment of dividend income.
We’re anxious to see whether or not the Dow Industrials and Dow Transports can exceed their respective 2011 highs. Such a breach would indicate an end to the current cyclical bear market run and the beginning of a cyclical bull market. However, the overhang of a secular bear market, marked by the October 2007 high, provides considerable resistance to even higher levels.
Please consider donating to the New Low Observer. Thank you.
Dow Theory: Bullish Implications
This week the Dow Jones Industrial Average and Dow Jones Transportation Average provided indications that, according to Dow Theory, have bullish implications. On October 14, 2011, the closing of the Industrials above 11,613.53 and the Transports above 4,684.44 suggests that the indexes will at least rise to the July highs and maybe even the April 2011 highs.
This bullish implication stands juxtapose to the bear market confirmation that was received when the Industrials and Transports simultaneously declined to new lows on October 3, 2011. Our view is that we’re still in a cyclical bear market that cannot become a cyclical bull market until both indexes exceed the April and July highs. To become a secular bull market, the Industrials and Transports need to go above their 2007 high.
Some would suggest that for anyone to wait until the indexes rise to the 2011 highs there would be a lot of missed investment opportunities. However, as we’ve indicated many times in the past, we use Dow Theory signals as an allocation indicator. During bull markets, we put more money to work and the opposite is true when there is a bear market indication. There are few instances when we’re completely out of the market for an extended period of time based on a bear market indication, as demonstrated in our 2008 investment transactions. Therefore, we have little concern for “missed” opportunities.
Additionally, although we got a bear market signal on August 2, 2011, which was 96 days after the April 29, 2011 peak in the Industrials, our portfolios were up for the year. After reallocating our investment positions upon getting the bear signal, we were able to reinvest in quality companies, sometimes the same stocks, at significantly lower prices.
The coming market volatility will provide great opportunities for traders and allow investors a chance to cash out of otherwise undesirable positions and take profits. Our expectation is that the Dow will go to the July 2011 highs before struggling at the May 2011 highs. Again, we’re still in a cyclical bear market until the Transports and Industrials exceed their respective 2011 highs.
Related article: A Lesson in Dow Theory published November 7, 2010
Please consider donating to the New Low Observer. Thank you.
Posted in aggressive trader, asset allocation, conservative investor, Dow Theory
Tagged members
Dow Theory: Bear Market Downside Target
On August 2, 2011, we received what is widely understood to be a Dow Theory bear market indication. According to Dow Theory, a bear market indication shall remain in place until counteracted by a bullish indication. The middle ground, where there is not a new bear market confirmation nor a new bull market signal, is generally considered a range or a “line.”
On August 9, 2011, we presented what we believed to be bear market rally targets according to Dow Theory. In the comment section of that same article, we revised the bear market rally targets based on the low of the Dow Industrials set on August 10, 2011.
The first bear market rally target, which seems next to impossible for the Dow Industrials to stay above, is 11,416.80. This level was only the first of five upside targets that would need to be breached for any prospect that a renewed cyclical bull market is in the works.
A confirmation of the bear market would be signaled if the Dow Industrials and Dow Transports were to fall below 10,719.94 and 4,149.94, respectively.
According to Dow Theory, we are still in a bear market and the early unconfirmed indications are that we may be headed to the 9,686.48 level.
Dow Theory: Bear Market Remains as INDPRO Surges
On Tuesday August 16th, it was reported that the current unadjusted Industrial Production Index (INDPRO) rose to 94.1525 for the month of July from the June level of 93.3075 which exceeded the March 2011 unadjusted high of 93.0943 (adj. 93.0770). We'll have to watch closely in the coming months to determine if the INDPRO tops out with the July or August figures.
In our recent Dow Theory analysis of August 2, 2011, we indicated that we'd be surprised at an INDPRO figure that was above the March 2011 level. As new information has come in (i.e. government revisions of the data) it appears that we have to allow for some time to pass before the stats are "finalized." We'll definitely provide updates as the revised data presents solid indications on the direction of the economy or confirmation of Dow Theory.
So far, the market still retains the Dow Theory bear market indication. Additionally, there continues to be resistance, on the part of the Dow Jones Industrial Average, to convincingly close above the first bear market rally target of 11,416.80. We don't believe that it is advisable to take on new positions unless they are considered speculative in nature, which means that you're willing to accept all losses.
With a new cyclical bull market initiated when the Dow Jones Industrial Average and Dow Jones Transportation Average go above their respective highs for 2011, the missed opportunity for investment gains on new purchases between now and then are worthwhile. When the next bull market indication is provided, our Dividend and Nasdaq 100 watch lists will point you to ideal investment candidates at reasonable values.
Please consider donating to the New Low Observer. Thank you.
Posted in bear market rally targets, Dow Theory, Industrial Production Index
Tagged members
2 Years of Profitable Dow Theory Analysis
Below are the articles that take you from the beginning of a cyclical bull market indication starting on July 24, 2009 to a bear market indication on August 2, 2011. Although it is possible to have a change from the current bear market indication to a bull market indication at a moments notice, we're willing to submit that an uninterrrupted bull market indication in a two year period within a secular bear market has yielded the intended results. In some instances, these articles can be found on Seeking Alpha.com (found here) with added commentary from those who had questions about the concepts or ideas on the topic of Dow Theory.
| Date | Article Title | Topic |
| 8/2/2011 | Dow Theory: August 2, 2011 | A new bear market begins, bull market ends |
| 6/30/2011 | Waiting for Confirmation | Bull market confirmation, next target Apr & May high |
| 6/24/2011 | Dow Theory: Price and Values | Values, price, seeking fair profits |
| 6/13/2011 | Russell: Wrong about the Industrial Production Index | Industrial Production: 1929 and today |
| 5/4/2011 | Price Decline equals Dividends Canceled | Values, dividends, fair profit |
| 4/6/2011 | Richard Russell's Miscue | Russell says 2007-2009 was not bear market |
| 4/6/2011 | Dow Theory: Cyclical Bull Market Confirmed | cyclical bull market confirmation |
| 2/14/2011 | Dow Theory: Continuation of Bull Market Confirmed | cyclical bull market confirmation |
| 11/8/2010 | Dow Theory Q&A | Primary trends, confirmations, S&P in Dow Theory |
| 11/7/2010 | A Lesson In Dow Theory | When to buy, sell, and wait for confirmation |
| 11/4/2010 | Dow Theory: Continuation of Bull Market Confirmed | cyclical bull market confirmation |
| 9/25/2010 | Seeking Ten Percent | Seeking pair profits |
| 9/8/2010 | Dow Theory: The Formation of a Line | Lines |
| 8/5/2010 | Dow Theory, Stock Markets and Economic Forecasting | Economic forecasting, stock markets |
| 6/30/2010 | Dow Theory | Bear market non-confirmation |
| 5/13/2010 | Dow Theory | Secondary reactions |
| 4/13/2010 | Dow Theory Q&A | When to sell; asset allocation |
| 4/11/2010 | Dow Theory | cyclical bull market confirmation |
| 3/23/2010 | Dow Theory | cyclical bull market confirmation |
| 2/23/2010 | Dow Theory Q&A | Manipulation; Averages discount everything |
| 2/22/2010 | Dow Theory | 50% principle |
| 1/24/2010 | Dow Theory | Downside targets |
| 1/19/2010 | Dow Theory on Fair Value | Values and Price |
| 1/10/2010 | Dow Theory | confirmation; line; 50% principle |
| 9/24/2009 | Dow Theory | retest recent lows; going higher |
| 9/2/2009 | Dow Theory | Double tops and Double bottoms |
| 8/25/2009 | Dow Theory | Russell changes from bear to bull |
| 8/24/2009 | Dow Theory | possible non-confirmation |
| 7/24/2009 | Dow Theory | a new bull market begins, bear market ends |
We hope you have profited from our analysis and enjoyed our contributions to the topic of Dow Theory.
Please consider donating to the New Low Observer. Thank you.
Bear Market Rally Targets
Now that a bottom has been established, within the context of a bear market, we can calculate the bear market rally targets according to Dow Theory. The upside targets are:
- 11,527.87
- 11.767.18
- 12,073.49
- 12,724.41
- 12,807.51
A new bull market would be considered when the Dow Industrials and Dow Transports jointly exceed the prior highs set in May 2011, respectively.
Please consider donating to the New Low Observer. Thank you.
Posted in bear market rally targets, Dow Theory
Dow Theory: Q&A
A reader has asked, “if the bear market is confirmed, do you see a possible longer term test of the lows from ’08 [2009]?”
This question is predicated on the fact that the Dow Jones Industrial Average confirms the March low as the Transports plumbed both the June and March lows. Dow Theory relies heavily on confirmations of the two key indexes and without such there is no theory.
In addition, we’ve included Robert Rhea’s use of the Industrial Production Index as an indicator to watch for. If the Industrial Production Index exceeds the prior high while the Dow Industrials fail to decline below the March low then we’ll be in a no-man’s land, which would require that the Dow Industrials and Transports exceed the May high to get a change from the current bearish condition.
From a Dow Theory perspective, the downside target relies heavily on the concept of the 50% principle. Although mistakenly attributed to E. George Schaefer by Richard Russell, the 50% principle is derived from Charles H. Dow’s “great law of action and reaction.” Dow describes the “law” in the following manner:
“The market is always responsive to the great law of action and reaction. The longer the swing one way the longer it will be the other. One of the best general rules in speculation is the theory that reaction in an advance or a decline will be at least one-half of the primary movement [50% principle].“The fact that the law is working through short ranges and long ones at the same time makes it impossible to tell with certainty what any particular swing may do; but for practical purposes, it is not infrequently wise to believe that when a stock has risen 10 points, and as a result of one or two short swings [double tops] does not go above the high point, but rather recedes from it, that it will gradually work off 4 or 5 points.[1]”
In another excerpt from Dow’s work, on the topic of the 50% principle, Dow says:
“It often happens that the secondary movement in a market amounts to 3/8 to ½ of the primary movement.[2]”
Again, Dow emphasis the concept of the 50% principle:
“Whoever will study our averages, as given in the Journal for years past, will see how uniformly periods of advance have been followed by periods of decline, amounting in a large proportion of cases to from one-third to one-half of the rise. [3]”
Finally, George Bishop, one of the greatest authors on the topic of Charles H. Dow, concludes:
“The law of action and reaction applies to both the general market and to individual stocks. This law states that the reaction to an advance or decline will approximate half the original movement.[4]”
As far as we know, the concept of applying what is commonly known as fibonacci numbers to indexes and individual stock prices was never published before Dow’s time and yet Dow is often quoted offering up such indications in the Wall Street Journal. So pervasively is the “law of action and reaction” applied to stocks that free online stock charting software allows an investor to automatically indicate the fibonacci numbers with little reference to Dow’s use of such parameters for declines or increases from a primary trend.
Based on the chart above, the 50% principle, or law of action and reaction, indicates that the next downside target at 38% is 10,417 and at 50% is 9,679. We first must reach these downside targets in order to then project the next stage of the decline.
While we believe that a fibonacci 5th wave is possible, meaning that the index could fall below the prior low of March 2009, we have seen that this type of action can be deceptive and costly to those who gamble big in the belief that the low of the 5th wave will be substantially lower than 6440. We covered this topic in an October 16, 2009 article titled “Stock Market Projections”:
“The second type of market low is based on the premise that the Dow fulfills the Wave principle and falls below the upward trending line (red) to the old support level 8100 and then 6440. A true Wave move down to the old low would bring the market below 6440. However, the last time this was fulfilled, in the period from 1970 to 1974, the market only fell 8.5% below the previous low of 631.16 on the Dow Industrials in 1970. Additionally, the Industrials ran up from 631.16 in 1970 to 1051.70 in 1973, an increase of 118% of the previous peak. As more time passes I expect the index to fall to 5474 if we do manage to complete a Wave formation on the downside.”
The prior piece suggests that anything is possible between the point where we are and the point we expect to be going towards. Our personal investing experience as demonstrated by our claim of 40% gains (going long only) from January 2008 to August 2008 and closing out 2008 with +14% gains suggests that getting out of the market entirely is not exactly the solution to a bear market signal. Charles Dow has commented on this matter:
"Even in a bear market, this method of trading will usually be found safe, although the profits taken should be less because of the liability of weak spots breaking out and checking the general rise.[5]"
Finally, we do need to emphasis that our analysis of the market is subject to change as conditions change. After the very first Dow Theory bull market indication in July of 2009, we have had to continually update the status of the indexes based on all significant and indications. Since that time, we’ve issued more than ten confirmations that the trend was bullish.
Likewise, we will have to revisit our August 2nd call with relevant updates that support or change our view. For now, the market bias is definitely bearish and would require both the Dow Industrials and Dow Transports to exceed the previous May 2011 highs to change our current view.
Citations:
[1] Dow, Charles H. Wall Street Journal. October 19, 1900.
[1] Bishop, George. Charles H. Dow and the Dow Theory. Appleton-Century-Crofts. New York. 1960. page 119.
[1] Sether, Laura. Dow Theory Unplugged. W&A Publishing. 2009. page 112.
[2] Dow, Charles H. Wall Street Journal. January 22, 1901.
[2] Bishop, George. Charles H. Dow and the Dow Theory. Appleton-Century-Crofts. New York. 1960. page 120.
[2] Sether, Laura. Dow Theory Unplugged. W&A Publishing. 2009. page 117.
[3] Dow, Charles H. Wall Street Journal. January 30, 1901
[3] Bishop, George. Charles H. Dow and the Dow Theory. Appleton-Century-Crofts. New York. 1960. page 120.
[3] Sether, Laura. Dow Theory Unplugged. W&A Publishing. 2009. page 199.
[4] Bishop, George. Charles H. Dow and the Dow Theory. Appleton-Century-Crofts. New York. 1960. page 231.
[5] Schultz, Harry D. A Treasury of Wall Street Wisdom. Investors' Press. (New Jersey, 1966). p. 12. Additional commentary here.
Please consider donating to the New Low Observer. Thank you.
Posted in 50% principle, Dow Theory, law of action and reaction
Dow Theory: August 2, 2011
In a first since the bear market bottom of March 9, 2009 and the bull market indication that initiated the New Low Observer on July 24, 2009, the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the Dow Jones Transportation Average has signaled the beginning of a bear market.
The last confirmation of the bull market that we received was on April 6, 2011. At that time we suggested that the market, as a leading indicator for the economy would continue to rise for “…at least for the next month and a half….” As far as the market is concerned, the top came in early May.
Almost as a total shock to some, the announcement of the extension of the debt ceiling didn't help the market in the least. In fact, one could have applied the adage “buy the rumor (of a deal), and sell the news.”
Today, the Dow indexes continued to slump and ended the day down more than 2%. While we would look for a breach of the June 2011 low to be a key indicator of the bearish trend, we’re primarily focused on the March 2011 low to be the most revealing level. The charts below graphically make clear what may become the trend for the market over the next several months.
Starting back in May 2011, both indices had risen to the high then retraced (secondary reaction) in June before heading higher. The Transports took off and broke above the May high hitting 5,618 (point A1). The Industrial, however, failed to confirm by going to a new high and reached only 12,724 (point A2). This first non-confirmation was a definite sign of bearishness, although it did not signal a bear market had begun.
As our April 6, 2011 Dow Theory article indicated, “What we see from the Transports on the way up we may also see on the way down.” Today was no exception to that idea. The Transports didn’t bother falling to the prior secondary reaction levels set in June, instead it plummeted past the March 2011 low. Both the Industrials and the Transports closed the day lower than such key support as noted in point B. The Industrials closed slightly below at 11,866 (point B1) while the Transports tumbled to 4,942 (point B2).
What is most worrisome now is that the Transports have taken out both the June low and the March low of 4,950 as seen on the chart at point C2. The Industrial index may appear to have quite a distance to go, but our calculations reveal that it would take only 2.1% decline for the index to confirm the Transports (point C1) action. Confirmation of the March lows by the Dow Industrials would be a devastating signal for the stock market and economy going forward.
The characteristics of the market in the last several months is not unlike what was experienced back in November 2007 when Richard Russell wrote and excellent article on the bearish Dow Theory implications for Barron's (article here). The similarities between now and 2007 don’t end there. The charts of the Industrial Production Index (INDPRO) show a pattern of trying to achieve new highs in 2007 and the present but then failing.
The connection between the Industrial Production Index and Dow Theory is well established as put forth by the Dow Theorist Robert Rhea. Our last article (found here ) on the Industrial Production Index made clear the importance of considering the movements of this indicator.
We’d be jumping to conclusions if we went so far as to conclude that the July Industrial Production Index numbers would not exceed the March 2011 high of 93.0943. However, we would be surprised if the INDPRO, despite already being so close to the high, manages to go above the numbers that were set in June and March 2011.
The caveat to our analysis on the Dow Industrials and Dow Transports is the possibility that the Industrials actually don’t go below the low set in March 2011 (considered a divergence or non-confirmation of the trend). If the Dow Industrials do not confirm the same lows as the Transports then we’d essentially be in a Dow Theory no-man’s land. Under such conditions, the bias should be towards being bearish but on a wait and see basis.
Please consider donating to the New Low Observer. Thank you.
Posted in bear market, Dow Theory
Dow Theory: Waiting for Confirmation
Recent activity in the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) has given favorable indications that we may reach a confirmation of the bullish trend that has been established since July 2009. Below is a chart of the DJIA for the last six months.
On the DJIA chart are several characteristics worth noting. First, and what we believe to be the most important, is the ability for the DJIA to break above the fair value level (yellow line). The fair value level, also referred as the 50% principal, indicates where a majority of investors in the index of stocks are at a break-even point with their investment.
Next is the unconfirmed bull market indication at point A (red line). Occurring at the same time that the DJIA is above the fair value level is the fact that the index broke above point A (red line) which indicates whether or not there is any conviction in the market to go higher. For the time being, there is plenty of conviction in the market as represented in the consecutive triple digit gains that have been posted despite the worrisome foreign and domestic economic news.
There are a couple of important points to highlight about the two positives that have been mentioned. First is the often misinterpreted view by some Dow Theorists to accept that if the price of the DJIA goes above point A (red line), then we’re in a confirmed bull market. In fact, this indication, going above point A, is only telling us that the next target for the index is to the previous high (point B; green line) and the trend is bullish. The market still has the opportunity to get a non-confirmation by either the Dow Jones Transportation Average or the Dow Jones Industrial Average not advancing to a new high (point B; green line). Lack of a confirmation from either index could weigh heavily on the prospects of a market advance.
The next issue dovetails with the first. By going above the fair value plane, it could be interpreted that the market, on a short-term basis, is overvalued. Not only could the market be considered to be overvalued, we could also consider that there is a built-in upper limit for the market. Many investors could interpret the prior high (point B; green line) for the DJIA to be as much risk, in a 2-year doubling of the market, as they’re willing to accept.
Each of these concerns are at play when new information comes in that implies risk is being added to the market. The problems with Greece, US deficit and debt, municipal default, inflation in China, and nuclear threat to Japan are already factored in for the next 3-9 months. There has to be a new twist on the current themes or a black swan event, something that no one has considered, to change the current message of the market.
As a follow up to prior commentary on Dow Theory, the DJTA continues to lead the way higher. In this case, the Transports fell the most (-8.45% v. –7.11%) from the peak in May and the DJTA recovered the most (+7.18% v. +4.35%). We continue to keep a watchful eye on the Dow Jones Transportation Average for any early indications of market direction (chart below).
Our best guess is that the upside prospects are for the DJIA and DJTA to go back to their respective highs set on April 29th and May 10th. Between now and then, investors should remain focused on our Dividend and Nasdaq 100 watch lists for new opportunities with companies that are undervalued and good long-term investments.
-
This is a follow-up to our last Dow Theory market call on April 4, 2011
Please consider donating to the New Low Observer. Thank you.
iShares Silver Trust (SLV) Debrief
On April 14, 2011, we provided what we believed to be the downside target for the Philadelphia Gold and Silver Index (XAU) in anticipation of the current decline that is taking place using Edson Gould’s speed resistance lines (article here). Although appearing to be very similar, there is a distinct difference between Gould’s resistance lines and Charles Dow’s 1/3 support levels. Gould’s lines have support levels based on 1/3 of high while Dow’s support levels are based on 1/3 the difference between the prior bottom and the most recent high.
In this review we’re going to tackle the trading pattern of the very controversial iShares Silver Trust (SLV). In the chart below we have drawn the Dow Theory support levels where the price of iShares Silver Trust (SLV) is likely to revert to as part of a normal reaction. As a point of clarification, according to Dow Theory, a bear market does not begin until the index or stock falls by at least 1/3 of the prior rise. In the case of (SLV), today’s closing price at $33.72 heralds what is sufficiently below the first support $34.52 and should be considered to be a bear market.
Although this could be considered a bear market based on Dow Theory, we only need to look back to 2008 to know how quickly and viciously a bear market in precious metals can begin and end. The precious metals bear market of 2008 crushed the XAU gold and silver stock index with a 68% decline in eight months. During the same time, the iShares Silver Trust (SLV) declined slightly more that 55%.
Bear market or not, some observations are worth considering. First, in the chart below, the overall pattern of the price decline in (SLV) for the Dow Theory indication numbered 1 (in green) is very similar to the current decline represented with the Dow Theory indication numbered 2 (in blue). Since Dow Theory works on a relative basis, once initiated at a major low, the signals provided are not confused through the distortions of large or small numbers. Headlines about SLV having declines of historic proportions are grossly exaggerated if there is no comparison on a percentage basis and compared to prior declines.
Second, at the beginning of each run at point 1 and 2, the price of SLV bounced off of the middle line B (also known as the 2/3 support line) before going parabolic.
Finally, the decline from each peak was rapid and vicious. One-third of the prior rise was wiped out in a matter of days after the peak.
What remains is a high level of uncertainty for (SLV) going forward. However, in general, we should see SLV tread water for a brief period of time before falling back to the prior low which began with the current run back in November 2008. Dow Theory suggests that a reasonable buying opportunity would exist at below line B (blue line B). However, we wouldn’t jump in at the slightest move below line B. Instead, we’d like to see the price decline to the dashed blue line at $15.41 or below.
Posted in Dow Theory, Edson Gould, gold, iShares Silver Trust, Silver, SLV, XAU
Price Decline Equals Dividends Canceled
The question of retaining profits on quality dividend companies through the selling of a position seems to counter the whole point of dividend investing. After all, aren’t you supposed to allow the dividends to compound? In a small way, we described one approach and our rational for selling quality companies after small gains in yesterday’s article (Our Primary Concern: Retaining Profits).
However, there is another way to view the rationale behind selling a dividend stock after a “fair profit.” In the early years of the Dow Theory Letters, Richard Russell would often cite a Robert Rhea quote about the impact of a stock decline. Rhea said:
“’Buying in bear markets is merely gambling and not very good gambling at that. Why not have cash instead of investments in bear markets? Why insist that one cannot afford to forego investment income when one day’s price shrinkage may cancel several years’ dividends?’”
The idea of canceling several years of dividends is at the forefront of our thinking when gains evaporate into losses. In Richard Russell’s Dow Theory Letter dated November 23, 1960, he presents, in literal terms, the impact of price decline and the loss of years of dividend income in the process. The table below is from Russell’s newsletter and needs little in the way of explanation.
![]() |
| Source: Richard Russell, Dow Theory Letters, http://www.dowtheoryletters.com/ |
Because stocks are not required to return principal with a stated yield as with many bonds, there is no assurance that the price will recover to the level that a purchase was initiated. Therefore, receiving short-term income on a dividend stock, although a necessary source of income for retired individuals, the prospect exists that an investor could end up with only a portion of the principal instead of the intended income plus principal.
The lack of assurance of principal and income with dividend stocks is why we believe people have become disenfranchised with technology stocks like Microsoft (MSFT) and Cisco Systems (CSCO). If they’ve invested in the stocks with the belief that they’re in it forever, when the decline comes, absent any dividend, there is little recourse or hope of recovering lost funds or keeping up with inflation.
Even new investors to Microsoft and Cisco Systems, aware of their bold promises in 1999 and subsequent failure to deliver in 2011, are asking themselves, “is it really worth facing the prospect of no return?” These questions are being asked when in some instances, especially with Microsoft, the timing probably couldn’t be better (especially now that they’re paying a dividend). Our supplementary comments on Microsoft can be found here.
While we subscribe to the Graham/Buffett principles of investing (buying for the long-term, you’re buying a business, concentrate on values, etc.) we assume that since there are only a handful of billionaires hewn strictly from investing in stocks, we might do well to hedge our thinking and strategy.
Finally, further analysis of Robert Rhea’s claim on not being invested at all during bear markets is something that is at odds with Charles Dow and we’ve decided is not appropriate or necessary. From our experience, bear markets are no guarantee of losses in your portfolio. Charles H. Dow, founder of the Wall Street Journal, has said that:
"Even in a bear market, this method of trading will usually be found safe, although the profits taken should be less because of the liability of weak spots breaking out and checking the general rise."
Schultz, Harry D., A Treasury of Wall Street Wisdom, Investors' Press, (New Jersey, 1966). p. 12. Additional commentary here.
Evidence of the fact that bear markets don’t always equal destruction of wealth, while going long stocks, is demonstrated in our 2007, 2008 and 2009 performance review. Naturally, 2008 is not expected to be replicated (having gains, while going long only, during a market decline of 40% or more). However, we do know that being all in or timing the market to be all out during bear markets shouldn’t be the goal. The goal, from our perspective, should be the preservation of gains whenever possible.
Please revisit New Low Observer for edits and revisions to this post.
Posted in CSCO, Dow Theory, Harry Schultz, MSFT, Richard Russell, Robert Rhea



















