Category Archives: Analyst Estimate

Canadian Dividend Watch List: October 2015

Toronto Stock Exchange

The accompanying chart of the Toronto Stock Exchange from 1979 to the present includes the work of Edson Gould’s Speed Resistance Lines (SRL).

image

What stands out is the coincidence of previous peaks, indicated by uppercase letters of the alphabet, being followed by declines to the current conservative downside target (8,450.30), at the respective lowercase letters.   The work of Gould isn’t a cure-all for what might happen in the stock market, however, it does provide a reasonable guideline to work from.

The coincidence of seven prior declines to the 8,450.30 level makes us wonder if the Toronto Stock Exchange has any chance to decline to the conservative downside target of 8,450.30, at (h).  It may asking much to suggest that the Toronto Stock Exchange could fall another -39.44% but if it does for some unknown reason then it would be good to have your resources (cash) at the ready.

Canadian Dividend Watch List: September 2015

The performance of the Canadian Watch List from September 2014 is listed below:

image

From left to right, the first five stocks on the list averaged a gain of +5.88% in the last year while the entire list averaged a loss of –8.90% compared to the Toronto Stock Exchange decline of –7.95%.

Of the companies listed, Just Energy (JE.TO), Transcontinental (TCL-A.TO) and North West Co. (NWC.TO) were the top three performers with an average gain of +36%.  At the bottom of the performance scale were Crescent Point Energy (CPG.TO), TransAlta (TA.TO) and AGF Management (AGF-B.TO) with an average loss of –51%.

Canadian Dividend Watch List September 2015

Nasdaq 100 Watch List: September 11, 2015

Canadian Dividend Watch List: August 2015

Below is the performance of the stocks that were on our Canadian Dividend Watch List from August 2014:

symbol Name 2014 2015 % Chg
TA.TO TransAlta Corp. 12.72 6.42 -49.53%
ESI.TO Ensign Energy Services Inc. 16.25 9.06 -44.25%
CGX.TO Cineplex Inc. 40.35 46.29 14.72%
RCI-B.TO Rogers Communications Inc. 43.24 46.9 8.46%
D-UN.TO Dream Office REIT 28.95 21.48 -25.80%
TLM.TO Talisman Energy Inc. 11.32 9.48 -16.25%
CMG.TO Computer Modelling Group Ltd. 12.46 11.68 -6.26%
CJR-B.TO Corus Entertainment Inc. 24.85 13 -47.69%
NWC.TO North West Company Inc. 24.29 27.12 11.65%
IGM.TO IGM Financial Inc. 50.64 36.24 -28.44%
CWT-UN.TO Calloway REIT 26.25 29.41 12.04%

The entire list lost –15.58% which is compared to the Toronto Stock Exchange decline of –12.16% in the period from August 15, 2014 to August 21, 2015.  The top five stocks on our list averaged a loss of –19.08% which is substantially more than the index.  Below we’ve outlined the performance of the watch list stocks compared to the analyst estimates.

image

This is one of the best examples (so far) of the analysts being accurate about the estimated price change that we’ve seen so far.  Talisman, TransAlta, Dream Office REIT, Rogers Communications, North West Co. and Cineplex all came within reasonable distance of the projected targets or move in the stock price.  The remaining stocks that did not meet expectations failed miserably and in a directions that was highly unfavorable to investors.

Canadian Dividend Watch List for August 2015

Below is the list of stocks that we think are worth your consideration and due diligence.

Canadian Dividend Watch List: July 2015

Performance Review

Below is the performance of the Canadian Dividend Watch List from July 2013:

symbol name 2013 2015 % chg
D-UN.TO Dundee REIT 31.77 24.7 -22.25%
REI-UN.TO Riocan Real Estate Investment Trust 25.11 27.06 7.77%
CUF-UN.TO Cominar REIT 20.83 17.97 -13.73%
CAR-UN.TO Canadian Apartment Properties REIT 22.31 28.45 27.52%
CWT-UN.TO Calloway REIT 26.09 30.17 15.64%
AX-UN.TO Artis Real Estate Investment Trust 15.1 13.68 -9.40%
IFC.TO Intact Financial Corporation 57.53 90.17 56.74%
FCR.TO First Capital Realty Inc. 17.79 18.29 2.81%
FTS.TO Fortis Inc. 32.34 36.99 14.38%
BEI-UN.TO Boardwalk Real Estate Investment Trust 60.3 59.78 -0.86%
EMA.TO Emera Inc. 33.75 42.55 26.07%
LB.TO Laurentian Bank of Canada 45.05 48 6.55%
TRP.TO TransCanada Corp. 46.77 49.34 5.49%
FTT.TO Finning International Inc. 22.68 21.9 -3.44%
NA.TO National Bank Canadian Equity SP 36.14 45.51 25.93%
CM.TO Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce 77.15 91.18 18.19%

The average return for the entire watch list was +9.84% compared to the Toronto Stock Exchange Composite index change of +13.33% in the period from July 19, 2013 to July 22, 2015.  At the time, we said the following of the watch list:

“We recommend careful examination of the listed companies in the REIT arena as they have less upside potential than is ideal.”

Since July 2013, the REIT related companies on the watch list generated a return of +0.94% while companies not in the REIT sector gained an average of +18.94%.

July 2015 Canadian Dividend Watch List

Below is the Canadian stocks of interest:

Canadian Dividend Watch List: June 19, 2015

Below is the 1-year performance of the Canadian dividend stocks from our June 2014 watch list (found here):

Symbol Name 2014 2015 % chg
JE.TO Just Energy Group Inc. 6.04 6.69 10.76%
D-UN.TO Dream Office REIT 28.9 24.97 -13.60%
TA.TO TransAlta Corp. 12.93 9.82 -24.05%
EMP-A.TO Empire Company Limited 67.44 89.4 32.56%
CUF-UN.TO Cominar REIT 18.65 17.9 -4.02%
NWC.TO North West Company Inc. 23.51 25.06 6.59%
GWO.TO Great-West Lifeco Inc. 29.37 36.37 23.83%
FTS.TO Fortis Inc. 31.75 36 13.39%
TLM.TO Talisman Energy Inc. 11.52 9.67 -16.06%
POW.TO Power Corporation of Canada 29.3 31.63 7.95%
ESI.TO Ensign Energy Services Inc. 16.78 11.59 -30.93%
PWF.TO Power Financial Corporation 32.88 35.93 9.28%

The performance of the analyst estimates fit with our view that analyst earnings expectations are aligned with past performance and not future reality.

image

In the watch list from last year, we commented on Just Energy:

“…it should be said that Just Energy (JE.TO) has been left for dead by analysts and therefore has the most potential for surprises on the upside.”

Coincidentally, Just Energy managed to gain +10.76% when the expectation was that the stock would fall significantly.

Analyst Estimates: May 15, 2015

Below are the price projections based on analyst earnings estimates for the first 20 stocks on our recent U.S. Dividend Watch List dated May 15, 2015. These estimates project the price change for the respective stocks in the next 12 months.

Analyst Estimate: DJ Utility Average March 2015

Below are the price projections of the components to the Dow-Jones Utility Index based on analyst earnings estimates as of March 8, 2015.  These estimates project the price change for the respective stocks in the next 12 months.

Continue reading

Analyst Estimates: February 20, 2015

Below are the price projections based on analyst earnings estimates for the stocks on our recent U.S. Dividend Watch List dated February 20, 2015.  These estimates project the price change for the respective stocks in the next 12 months.  The stocks listed below are only a select group that was not shown on our January 19, 2015 or February 6, 2015 analyst estimates.

Analyst Estimates

Below are the price projections based on analyst earnings estimates for the stocks on our recent U.S. Dividend Watch List dated February 6, 2015.  These estimates project the price change for the respective stocks by the end of 2015.  The stocks listed below are only a select group that was not shown on our January 19, 2015 analyst estimates.

Analyst Estimates: U.S. Dividend Watch List

Below are the price projections based on analyst earnings estimates for the stocks on our recent U.S. Dividend Watch List dated January 16, 2015.  These estimates project the price change for the respective stocks by the end of 2015.

Analyst Estimates

Below are the price projections based on analyst earnings estimates for the stocks on our recent Nasdaq 100 Watch List dated January 9, 2015.  These estimates project the 1 year price change for the respective stocks.

2015 Estimated Price Changes for Dow Industrials

Below are the estimated price changes for the components of the Dow Jones Industrial Average in the coming year.  The price estimates are based on the current analyst low expectation of annual earnings assuming the stock retains the p/e ratio at the end of 2014.

image

Our experience has been that stocks that are expected to underperform generally do much better than those stocks that are expected to increase in the coming year.

As a test, we’re comparing the performance of the “end of 2014 p/e ratio” against the performance of the stocks if they all had a p/e ratio of 15 as depicted below.

image

Analyst Estimate: U.S. Dividend Watch List

Performance Review

On January 16, 2014, we posted a watch list with the analyst estimates for the expected performance for the coming year.  Below are the graphs with the estimated price changes…

image

…followed by the actual changes as of December 29, 2014.

image

Again, the stocks with the lowest expectations outperformed the stocks that had the highest expections, according to their analysts.

Below is a snapshot of the latest analysts low estimated earnings from our recent U.S. Dividend Watch List.

Canadian Dividend Watch List: August 15, 2014

Below is the list of Canadian stocks that are currently on our radar along with the projected price appreciation:

Continue reading