U.S. Dividend Watch List: December 26, 2014

Top Five Watch List Performance Review

In our ongoing review of the NLO Dividend Watch List, we have taken the top five stocks on our list from December 27, 2013 and have checked the performance one year later. The top five companies on that list can be seen in the table below.

Symbol Name 2013 Price 2014 Price % change
ED Consolidated Edison 55.05 67.76 23.1%
SCG SCANA Corporation 46.96 62.27 32.6%
PM Philip Morris International 86.74 83.34 -3.9%
MXIM Maxim Integrated Products, Inc. 28.10 31.65 12.6%
NHI National Health Investors Inc. 56.32 70.26 24.8%
      Average 17.8%
         
DJI Dow Jones Industrial 16,221.14 17,804.80 9.8%
SPX S&P 500 1,818.32 2,070.65 13.9%

Watch List Review

Our top five companies outperformed the market by a decent margin thanks to two utility companies, Consolidated Edison (ED) and SCANA Corp (SCG). We were completely wrong about the direction of these two companies. We said of utilities at the time that "...we remain bearish on the sector." In hindsight, we were completely wrong about the timing of the call.

We also highlighted Target (TGT) in our review. Although the stock wasn't among the top five, we were convinced that the stock had potential given the one-time event of hacking which brought the stock down. We said:

Events such as this one should not alter the underlying business of the company in the long run. At 16x earnings and a 2.77% dividend yield, we may be tempted to start building a position in the near future.

We took a position in Target on February 12th and the stock is up +31% since.

U.S. Dividend Watch List: December 26,2014

The holiday shortened week didn't stop the market from moving forward. The S&P 500 was up +1.3% while the Dow broke the 18k mark and was up +1.5% for the week. Below are 28 companies on our watch list. Continue reading

Nasdaq 100 Watch List: December 26, 2014

Performance Review

The December 6, 2013 watch list contained the following companies and resulted in the accompanying 1-year results:

Symbol 2013 2014 % change
CTRX 44.99 51.93 15.43%
ALTR 32.12 38.27 19.15%
ISRG 377.38 531.24 40.77%
MXIM 28.46 31.65 11.21%
CHRW 57.89 76.75 32.58%
EBAY 52.01 57.04 9.67%
EQIX 165.48 232.76 40.66%
GOLD 65.44 66.26 1.25%

The companies on our watch list from last year gained an average of +21.34% as compared to the Nasdaq 100 which gained +23.11%.  Our analyst estimate section of the watch list from last year shows what the stock on our list were expected to do over the following 12 months.

image

All of the stocks were expected to decline in value, overall.  However, what is most striking about the one year performance is that while companies on the far left were expected to do the worst those on the far right were expected to the best (sort of).  Below is the actual one year performance:

image

A side by side comparison will demonstrate that (again) the trend of performance favors those stocks that have been pinned with the worst expectations.

Nasdaq 100 Watch List: December 26, 2014

The following stocks are on our radar and should be on yours:

Lifespan of Corporations in the S&P 500

On December 4, 2014, the folks at Zerohedge.com (ZH) came out with a blurb titled “Here Is The Reason Why The Average Lifespan Of US Corporations Has Never Been Shorter”.  Overall, the ZH piece is another “…the end is nigh…” narrative that has been a consistent theme since their inception.  The ZH team highlighted the following in reference to James Montier’s GMO article titled “World's Dumbest Idea”, “...there is one point that bears emphasis: the plunge in S&P500 corporate lifespans to record lows…”.

To be specific, Montier says, “One of the other features that stands out as having changed significantly between the era of managerialism and the era of SVM is the lifespan of a company and the tenure of the CEO. Both have shortened significantly.” Also included is the following chart from Montier’s article.

image

On the surface, the evidence and the claim seem to line up pretty well.  As the chart demonstrates, from 1971 to the present, the lifespan of companies in the S&P 500 has consistently declined.  However, there is one observation that stands out in the chart above. What makes it possible for the age of companies in the index to rise or fall within the range of the declining trend?

The age of the companies can increase or decrease simply because companies are added and dropped from the index.  There is no requirement that the stocks in the S&P 500 have a minimum or maximum number of years under their belt in order to be included.  Additionally, investors increasingly demand that the indexes are more reflective of the modern era rather than some bygone periods (a mistake for those who wish to have reliable index).

With this in mind, it has become the nature of the S&P 500 committee to add and drop companies with a frequency and magnitude that nullifies the point of an index.  As an example, since 2003, 37% of the S&P 500 index has been added/dropped.  The average number of companies dropped from the index is 15 each year.

In 2014, eight companies were added to the index.  According the D&B Million Dollar Database, of the companies added to the index, the average age was 19 years.  Using the same database, the companies that were dropped from the index had an average age of 64 years.

Date Added Dropped
3/21/2014 Keurig Green Mountain (1993) WPX Energy (2011)
4/1/2014 Essex Property (2007) Cliff Natural Resources (2011)
6/20/2014 Cimarex Energy (2007) International Game Tech. (1980)
6/30/2014 Affilliated Managers Group (1993) Forest Laboratories (1985; Actavis)
7/1/2014 Martin Marietta Materials (1993) United States Steel (1901)
8/14/2014 Mallinckrodt (1986) Rowan (1948)
9/19/2014 United Rentals (1997) Graham Holdings (1877)
9/19/2014 Universal Health Services (1979) Peabody Energy (1883)

As the drive and desire for performance increases, the age of corporations and tenure of CEOs in S&P 500 companies will likely decrease.  Since the S&P 500 collection of companies does not act like an index, instead merely a reflection of the whims of a speculator, investors should not be alarmed with the age of companies or tenure of CEOs presented to us by S&P handlers.  The changes that have occurred since 1971 are a reflection of overreaching on the part of the index managers.

The lifespan of companies in the index does not mean death and dissolution of companies dropped from the index.

GoPro Downside Target Met

On October 8, 2014, when GoPro (GPRO) was trading at $89.93 we concluded our review of downside targets for the stock with the following commentary:

“This review of GPRO is to determine how accurate the downside targets are.  In addition to the current downside targets, the upside target is indicated to be $103.40.  The parabolic nature of the current rise may not be over.  However, depending on the length of time that passes, investors/speculators interested in GPRO would do well to wait for the stock to fall below the ascending $45.50 before reconsidering the merits of this stock.”

Below is the same chart that was used from October 8th with data to the present.

image

GoPro has achieved our downside target and appears to be on the rebound assuming it can exceed the $60 level.  Speculators should keep an eye on the $31.28 level as it is a legit downside target if the $60 level fails to hold.  This means putting only ¾ of the intended amount into GPRO with the remaining ¼ for the “unlikely” event of falling to $31.28.

Canadian Dividend Watch List: December 2014

Performance Review

Our December 2013 watch list contained 14 companies.  The 1-year performance is listed below.

Symbol Name 2013   2014   % change
D-UN.TO Dundee REIT 28.22   24.89   -11.80%
CUF-UN.TO Cominar REIT 17.92   18.39   2.62%
FTS.TO Fortis Inc. 30.31   37.96   25.24%
CWT-UN.TO Calloway REIT 24.72   27.25   10.23%
CAR-UN.TO Canadian Apartment Properties REIT 20.84   24.41   17.13%
TA.TO TransAlta Corp. 13.38   10.71   -19.96%
REI-UN.TO Riocan Real Estate Investment Trust 24.54   26.91   9.66%
SAP.TO Saputo, Inc. 24.12   33.96   40.80%
CU.TO Canadian Utilities Ltd. 35.26   39.01   10.64%
FCR.TO First Capital Realty Inc. 17.5   18.65   6.57%
EMA.TO Emera Incorporated 30.63   38.10   24.39%
REF-UN.TO Canadian REIT 42.08   46.16   9.70%
AX-UN.TO Artis Real Estate Investment Trust 14.65   14.32   -2.25%
ESI.TO Ensign Energy Services Inc. 16.42   10.91   -33.56%

At the time, our analysis of the list was summed up in the following commentary:

“As we’ve indicated in the past, companies that are typically expected to experience the most decline under the lowest earnings scenario are often the ones that outperform in the following year.  We will see if TransAlta, Fortis, Emera, First Capital Realty and Saputo manage to exceed the performance of the stocks currently expected to be in the positive one year from now.  Because of our bias on this matter, we favor the stocks expected to decline in price based on analyst low estimates.”

Our commentary was based on estimates of price change using analyst earnings projections for the coming year (2014) as seen below:

image

Below is a graphical representation of the change that has occurred in the last year:

image

As has been the case time and again, the stocks that were expected to do the worst actually outperformed the stocks that were anticipated to do the best.  Of the five companies (TransAlta, Fortis, Emera, First Capital Realty and Saputo) that were expected to decline in value averaged a gain of +15.41%.  Of the remaining stocks that were expected to increase, the average gain was +0.22%.  The entire list gained +6.39% while the Toronto Stock Exchange gained +6.48%.

Of interest to all investors is the performance of TransAlta (TA.TO) down –19.96% and Canadian Apartment Properties (CAR-UN.TO) up +17.13%.  The analyst low expectations of these stocks were extremely accurate.  We’re hoping that the analysts tracking these stocks could achieve a repeat performance.

Canadian Dividend Watch List: December 2014

This is a list of Canadian dividend stocks that are currently on our radar. For those wishing to find the most complete fundamental information on these companies, we recommend visiting one of Canada’s leading financial websites, the Financial Post (found here). However, Yahoo!Finance probably has the better long-term charts and historical dividend data.

Continue reading

U.S. Dividend Watch List: December 19, 2014

Top Five Watch List Performance Review

In our ongoing review of the NLO Dividend Watch List, we have taken the top five stocks on our list from December 20, 2013 and have checked the performance one year later. The top five companies on that list can be seen in the table below.

Symbol Name 2013 Price 2014 Price % change
ED Consolidated Edison 54.77 65.69 19.9%
MLM Martin Marietta Materials 96.17 119.26 24.0%
PM Philip Morris International 85.52 83.05 -2.9%
IBM IBM 180.02 158.51 -11.9%
T AT&T Inc 34.30 33.54 -2.2%
      Average 5.4%
         
DJI Dow Jones Industrial 16,221.14 17,804.80 9.8%
SPX S&P 500 1,818.32 2,070.65 13.9%

Watch List Review

The best performer was Martin Marietta Materials (MLM).  While the stock ended the year up +24%, it gained as much +43% within 6 months.  We were skeptical about the stock at such a high multiple a year ago (P/E of 42) but that was because the company was expected to grown their net income by 49% (from $2.60 in 2013 to $3.87 in 2014).  As of this writing, analysts expect the company to earn $3.48 in 2014 which is 10% less than projected.  Analysts now expect the company to earn $5.19 per share in 2015 which is a 49% increase from 2014 and brings the forward P/E to 22.  It would be interesting to see how this projection plays out in the face of a global slowdown.  We believe that one of the key elements that should help in 2015 is falling oil prices.  While oil isn’t a direct input into the company's material cost, we assume that the cost to transport their product should be reduced substantially.

The second best performer from our top five was Consolidated Edison (ED). Our expectation was that the stock would under-perform the market but that didn't pan out. It turns out that interest rates continued to fall as the deflationary environment persisted. The stock now yield 2.5% which is extremely low for a utility company. It is hard to say that the stock is of good value.

IBM (IBM) was the worst performing out of the top five. The most interesting thing is that, at the time, IBM had the lowest P/E ratio. This goes to show that while buying stock with low P/E ratio may appear to be a safe bet, one shouldn't rely on a single ratio as a determination of value.

U.S. Dividend Watch List: December 19,2014

This volatile market has taken investors on a roller coaster ride. The market rose +3.4% for the week. As such, our watch list contracted to contain 39 companies. Continue reading

Gold Stock Indicator: December 19, 2014

Gold stocks were up while gold was down for the past week.  However, this isn’t a complete picture of what it took for gold stocks end the week up.  The chart below shows the dramatic loss of –7% by late Tuesday and the subsequent gain of +10% by early Friday.

image

Nasdaq 100: 2014 Re-Rank Review

On December 12, 2014, the Nasdaq OMX Group announced the names of the companies that would be added and dropped from the Nasdaq 100 Index.  The following  are the companies that have been added and dropped from the index:

Symbol Name Price P/E EPS Yield Price/Book Action
EA Electronic Arts Inc. 47.24 38.31 1.23 - 5.38 added
AAL American Airlines 50.14 97.93 0.51 0.8 7.04 added
LRCX Lam Research 80.82 20.68 3.91 0.9 2.55 added
FFIV F5 Networks, Inc. 132.84 32.48 4.09 - 6.96 dropped
EXPE Expedia Inc. 87.79 27.59 3.18 0.8 5.83 dropped
MXIM Maxim Integrated 31.2 25.57 1.22 3.7 3.61 dropped

Continue reading

U.S. Dividend Watch List: December 12, 2014

The market was down -3.5% for the week which pulled the year-to-date gains of +8.4%. Oil prices tanked and is currently trading under $60 a barrel. As a result, we are seeing more companies on our watch list than usual. The total number of companies increased from 40 to 75. Continue reading

Gold Stock Indicator: December 12, 2014

In the past two weeks, the price of gold has meandered in a tepid range.  Alternatively, gold stocks as represented by the Philadelphia Gold and Silver Stock Index decline –6.07%.

image

Continue reading

Quick Take: BHP Billiton

“It is the debtor that is ruined by hard times” -Rutherford B. Hayes, 19th President of the United States

Transaction Alert

U.S. Dividend Watch List: December 5, 2014

Top Five Watch List Performance Review

In our ongoing review of the NLO Dividend Watch List, we have taken the top five stocks on our list from December 6, 2013 and have checked the performance one year later. The top five companies on that list can be seen in the table below.

Symbol Name 2013 Price 2014 Price % change
ED Consolidated Edison 55.85 63.26 13.3%
IBM IBM 177.67 163.27 -8.1%
PM Philip Morris International 85.83 87.14 1.5%
NWN Northwest Natural Gas 41.78 47.18 12.9%
T AT&T Inc 34.53 33.94 -1.7%
      Average 3.6%
         
DJI Dow Jones Industrial 16,020.20 17,958.79 12.1%
SPX S&P 500 1,805.09 2,075.37 15.0%

Watch List Review

Cumulatively, our top five fail to keep up with the market.  Consolidated Edison (ED) was the best performer with a gain of 13%.  We were not too convinced that Consolidated Edison would do well in a rising rate environment.  While rate hasn’t risen, share have gained ground and drive dividend yield lower.

IBM (IBM) was the worse performing stock of these five companies.  We have mentioned before that fair value for the stock would be around $160 thus making the stock less attractive to our team.

U.S. Dividend Watch List: December 5,2014

Below are 40 companies that are worth considering on our watch list. Continue reading

Nasdaq 100 Watch List: December 5, 2014

Performance Review

Below is the watch list from December 6, 2013 and the subsequent performance over the last year:

Symbol Name 2013 2014 % change
CTRX Catamaran  44.99 51.25 13.91%
ALTR Altera Corp. 32.12 37.93 18.09%
ISRG Intuitive Surgical, Inc. 377.38 508.86 34.84%
MXIM Maxim Integrated 28.46 31.36 10.19%
CHRW CH Robinson Worldwide 57.89 74.63 28.92%
EBAY eBay Inc. 52.01 54.81 5.38%
EQIX Equinix, Inc. 165.48 231.68 40.00%
GOLD Randgold Resources 65.44 64.85 -0.90%
Average change 18.80%
Nasdaq 100 Index 23.04%

Below is the chart of analyst estimated returns from December 6, 2013 compared to the performance one year later:

image

In the example above, we see that, in general, the stocks performed in opposition to what analysts had anticipated.  It is important to note that we routinely recommend that investors consider the stocks that have the worst prospects first based on analyst estimates.  After appropriate due diligence, stocks deemed unacceptable risks should be eliminated.

As has been the case for some time, analyst estimates have fallen far from the mark when assessing the prospects for stocks.  At the time, Equinix (EQIX) was considered by analysts to have the worst prospects.  As it happens, Equinix managed to gain the most among the stocks that we tracked last year.  For our part, we had EQIX on our radar as early as July 26, 2013.  We said the following of the stock:

“A stock that is establishing a significant technical pattern is Equinix (EQIX).  It seems that Equinix is developing a ‘head and shoulder’ formation.  this suggests that a further decline below $176 will result in a minimum decline to the conservative downside target of $158.37.  We would consider a review of EQIX fundamentals at or below $110.”

Our concern for downside risk resulted in being too cautious.  However, after our July 26, 2013 commentary, EQIX declined from $183.75 to the Edson Gould SRL conservative downside target of $158.37.  Once achieving the low at $155, EQIX started to make the long climb higher.

image

Nasdaq 100 Watch List: December 5, 2014

The following are the stocks that are on our watch list with Analyst Estimates:

Gold Stock Indicator: November 28, 2014

Gold stocks were rocked this past week by falling more than –8% on Friday alone.  Gold declined by –3.04% for the week.

image