Top Five Watch List Performance Review
In our ongoing review of the NLO Dividend Watch List, we have taken the top five stocks on our list from June 27, 2014 and have checked the performance one year later. The top five companies on that list can be seen in the table below.
| Symbol |
Name |
2013 Price |
2014 Price |
% change |
| ROST |
Ross Stores |
32.90 |
50.27 |
52.8% |
| SCL |
Stepan |
52.35 |
55.00 |
5.1% |
| C |
Citigroup Inc |
47.14 |
56.34 |
19.5% |
| WWW |
Wolverine World Wide |
26.19 |
29.34 |
12.0% |
| FCBC |
First Community Bancshares |
14.38 |
18.52 |
28.8% |
| |
|
|
Average |
23.6% |
| |
|
|
|
|
| DJI |
Dow Jones Industrial |
16,851.84 |
17,946.68 |
6.5% |
| SPX |
S&P 500 |
1,960.96 |
2,101.61 |
7.2% |
Out top five companies surpassed the market performance by a wide margin. The overall gain was +23.60% compared with +7.20% for the S&P 500.
Ross Stores (ROST) was the largest contributor with a +52.8% gain. ROST also did a 2-to-1 split on June 12th of this year. Our assessment of Ross was inaccurate when we said that the stock doesn't have enough margin of safety at the current level. However, we may have identified a key attribute for stocks that may outperform the market. One of the biggest takeaway is the fact that ROST raised its dividend by +17% while maintaining a low payout ratio of 19%. The fact that the dividend yield was only 1.12% confirms our theory that the dividend growth and sustainability is more important than absolute yield.
Of the top five, Stepan (SCL) was the worst performer. The street had an optimistic view of the stock and expected it to grow net income by +36%. This made Stepan's forward P/E of 9 very attractive. However, that all depended on one important fact, that the net income must rise by more than a third. Because the stock was trading at its 5-year high on P/E, any earnings miss would not be good. When Stepan reported earnings in October 2014, the street expected EPS to come in at $0.89 but the actual result was $0.68. The stock fell from $52 to $38. Next, the inevitable event occurred, analysts revised their estimate downward. Stepan's EPS came in at $0.38 in the February quarter, above the street's estimate of $0.35. Three months later, EPS came in at $0.90 when the street's estimate was $0.68. Shares rose back from $38 to $55. 
U.S. Dividend Watch List: June 26, 2015
There are 33 companies on our watch list. Continue reading →