Top Five Watch List Performance Review
In our ongoing review of the NLO Dividend Watch List, we have taken the top five stocks on our list from January 23, 2015 and have checked the performance one year later. The top five companies on that list can be seen in the table below.
| Symbol |
Name |
2013 Price |
2014 Price |
% change |
| NUE |
Nucor Corp. |
43.80 |
35.36 |
-19.3% |
| EMR |
Emerson Electric |
58.12 |
43.17 |
-25.7% |
| ITT |
ITT Corp |
36.08 |
31.00 |
-14.1% |
| MCD |
McDonald's Corp. |
89.56 |
118.40 |
32.2% |
| HY |
Hyster-Yale Materials Handling, Inc. |
64.75 |
48.95 |
-24.4% |
| |
|
|
Average |
-10.3% |
| |
|
|
|
|
| DJI |
Dow Jones Industrial |
17,672.60 |
16,093.51 |
-8.9% |
| SPX |
S&P 500 |
2,051.82 |
1,906.90 |
-7.1% |
Watch List Review
Our top five lost an average of -10.3%. The best performer was McDonald (MCD) which gained an astonishing +32.2%. The driver for their success may be from menu changes (see here). We had some comments on Nucor (NUE) and Hyster-Yale (HY) which lost -19.3% and -24.4% respectively. Excerpts below were taken from our post from last year.
"Nucor (NUE) has lost -6.6% YTD and is trading right at the 52-week low. The company manufactures and sells steel and steel related products. The company recently raised their dividend by +0.05%. The small increase was a wise move because it kept the company on Dividend Achiever list while maintaining their cash position for the rocking time ahead. Interestingly, analysts at Goldman Sachs upgraded the stock to Buy from Neutral but lowered the price target to $52 from $55. The stock is trading at a slight discount to its 5-year average on all matrix (according to Morningstar). The stock is definitely worth considering at this level."
"One company that peaked our interest is Hyster-Yale (HY). The company was a spin-off from another Dividend Achiever, NACCO Industries, in 2012. Hyster-Yale manufactures forklifts. In less than one year, the stock has fallen from the high of $108 to settle at $65 by the end of the week, a -40% decline. Because Hyster-Yale is relatively young as a standalone company, we have little history on its financial. The stock currently trades at just 10x earnings with dividend yield of 1.6%. The company's balance sheet is strong with $39M in total debt while holding $97.9M in cash. Debt to equity ratio sits at 8.25. Hyster-Yale brings in $2.8B in revenue with net income of $109M or 3.9% profit margin. A razor thin margin is a cause for concern given that the company operates in a highly cyclical industry. However, current valuation is worth your consideration. The market cap is at $1B which is just 0.38x of sales."
Even though our speculation that these two would rise didn't come to fruition, this review provided us with an opportunity to reassess these two companies at a lower price. Although Nucor now yield 4.3%, it's payout ratio is high at 77%. Analysts are expecting the company net profits to be at $1.55 for the current year. With current earnings at $1.50, dividend increase will be put to question. Hyster-Yale currently sports a 2.37% dividend yield. Additionally, the payout ratio is 22% which is a large margin for safety for investors. While analysts expect their profits to fall, HY should be able to sustain the dividend if not increase it slightly.
U.S. Dividend Watch List: January 22, 2016
The S&P 500 continued to fluctuate between 1,820 and 1,900. Oil still hasn't hit bottom and commodities continued to slide lower. We see additional bearish sentiment as an opportunity to accumulate shares. Below are 41 companies on our watch list. Continue reading →